Tuesday, 7 July 2009

Stick that in your kettle

One of my distant superiors was involved in the design and defence of 'kettling', the police tactic of imprisoning legal protestors for long periods, allowing them out only if these innocent people surrender their details and images to cops for a database that's been declared illegal.

Well yah boo sucks to you, Professor: your methods have been described as 'inadequate' and outdated by the official report into the G20 events.

Some highlights:

Commanders appeared not to properly understand basic human rights laws or the legal requirements surrounding the use of kettling, the report said. However, O'Connor said this was the case for only some senior officers, and refused to identify those at fault.

It says police are currently failing in their human rights obligations, and describes public order policing guidance issued by the Association of Chief Police Officers – adopted by all forces across England and Wales – as "insufficient".

The national policy should be overhauled, it says, to "demonstrate explicit consideration of the facilitation of peaceful protest".

contrary to claims by senior Met officers ahead of the demonstrations, there was "no specific intelligence which suggested any planned intention to engage in co-ordinated and organised public disorder".

Despite that, senior commanders gave "no consideration" to the idea that the protests might be peaceful and planned how to deal "robustly" with unlawful activity.

Just to be clear: there are some individual officers behaving insensitively and criminally, but this report, and my point, is that there's a structural and institutional problem with policing when it comes to protest: the police force is far to the right of the population and shows no sign of recognising citizens' rights to peaceful protest.

2 comments:

Kate said...

I agree wholeheartedly Vole, but sadly I believe I am even more cynical than you. Of course there was no intelligence to suggest planned public disorder, the police purposefully initiated such a discourse to justify their heavy handed actions on the day. And as for kettling, what do kettles do? They boil. I'd say it's less a case of containing disorderly protesters and more a case of containing orderly protesters so as to provoke them to become disorderly, in order to justify their heavy handed tactics. The police are totally in league with the government, who have been relentless in reducing the powers of the public to peacefully protest since they came to power. What you see Voley is governmentality (Foucault); concerted efforts to control the population whilst subtly extending governmental power into new domains (so as most people do not notice or complain). Lets put it this way, I am often minded to peacefully protest but do not do so for fear of being bashed over the head with a truncheon or getting a criminal record when I've committed no crime. Look at what happened to the FITwatch ladies, or the E-ON protesters. Be afraid, be very afraid.... NO! WAIT! That's exactly how they want you to feel! Just like the doom (recession) and terror (war, murder) on the news every day. Oh aren't you glad we live in a 'democracy'?!

The Plashing Vole said...

You're absolutely right - and my angry protesting days are (probably) over for the same reasons. I've been re-reading Foucault recently too!