Showing posts with label select committee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label select committee. Show all posts

Tuesday, 19 July 2011

The Murdoch hearings, digested

So, James and Rupert Murdoch are giving evidence to Parliament.



It's not very enlightening. Murdoch Sr. seems to have been reading a lot of Beckett and Pinter: long pauses followed by monosyllabic replies. Sometimes he appears to be blaming his son. James seems to be suffering too: nobody calls him Mr. Murdoch, and his expressions betray hatred of not being the top dog in the room.

Their defence appears to be - rather implausibly - that they didn't know anything, nobody told them anything. They're completely surprised by the implication that there's anything untoward about press moguls have frequent, complete and secret access to Prime Ministers. Democracy, it seems, is an alien concept of which they've heard without being tempted to try.

In some ways, it's an object lesson in PR tactics. The Murdochs have clearly been coached: stay polite, talk for a long time but don't give anything away, reel off dates and figures to avid the impression of waffling. At times it gets farcical, reminding me of another character: 'that would be an ecumenical matter'. (Sorry about the ad, couldn't find one without).



It's not entirely working though. Murdoch Sr comes across as senile. Perhaps this is his tactic, but I suspect it's an inability to deal with a situation which he can't control. I doubt he's ever been compelled to answer questions or follow someone else's line of thought.

OK, it finished with Murdoch getting a custard pie in the face, the egregious Louise Mensch scraping together enough brain cells for a good question or two, and Murdoch dropping the senility act in favour of reading out a prepared statement that sounds ('my son and I') like he's apologising to the neighbours for James breaking a window with a football. And almost as sincere.

What we didn't learn was much about the command structures, who's paying for what, and what responsibility the Murdochs will take. Murdoch seems to feel that he's the victim ('I was betrayed by people trusted by people I trusted'). Humbug!

Monday, 4 April 2011

Back In The Box, Healthcare Issue

This is classic, top quality shenanigans. Sarah Wollaston is a Tory MP who was a doctor and is distinctly unimpressed by her party's insane plan to sell the NHS to their mates.

Obviously, you don't want independent thinkers around when the Select Committee on Health starts looking at the small print.

So you dispatch the most junior government minister in existence to her constituency on debate day so that she has to be there to welcome him and pose for photos rather than ask pointed questions and appear on TV interviews making awkward points.

The only trouble is that Dr Wollaston has to welcome a junior minister to her Devon constituency today and tomorrow.
Yes, it's Richard Benyon. On a two-day ministerial visit to the green pastures of south Devon. And no doubt her party colleagues impressed on Dr Wollaston how discourteous it would be for her to not be in Totnes when Mr Benyon was there.
Even if, as parliamentary under-secretary at Defra, he is one of the most junior members in the entire government.
His visit will make it a lot harder for Dr Wollaston to do TV interviews.
It was arranged at the last minute, I understand, and had been postponed from an early date.

Voilà: silence.

Another fine story unearthed by the odd Michael Crick. Brilliant shenanigans: it entirely privileges partisan politics over the good of the sick. This from the party that called for an end to spin and for 'new politics'.

Meanwhile, the cat's out of the bag, thanks to Tory Minister Greg Barker, in case there was any doubt that their attack on public services was more than nasty-minded ideological obsession:
We are making cuts that Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s could only have dreamt of.